Preface: “Cell phones are so convenient that they’re an inconvenience.”— Haruki Murakami
Managing Employee Cell Phone Use: A Guide for Business Owners
In today’s mobile-centric work environment, providing employees with cell phones or compensating them for work-related mobile use is increasingly common. Employers typically choose between three primary approaches: (A) issuing company-owned phones, (B) offering monthly stipends, or (C) reimbursing employees for business-related use of their personal devices. Each method has distinct tax implications and operational considerations.
Company-Issued Phones
If the mobile phone is provided primarily for non-compensatory business reasons—such as the need to contact employees during work-related emergencies—the value of the phone is generally excluded from the employee’s income. Occasional personal use is treated as a de minimis fringe benefit and is also nontaxable.
Benefits of company-issued phones include enhanced security as employers can enforce security protocols and manage devices centrally. Uniform hardware and software across the organization simplify IT support. Bulk purchasing and corporate plans may reduce per-unit costs.
Disadvantages include employees being reluctant to carry two devices, and managing inventory, repairs, and replacements adds to the IT workload.
Cell Phone Stipends
Stipends are generally considered nontaxable if they are provided for substantial non-compensatory business reasons and are not a substitute for wages.
Reasons for cell phone stipends include simplicity as fixed monthly payments are easy to administer. Employees can choose their preferred devices and plans.
Reasons not to use cell phone stipends include potential tax risks. If stipends are not properly documented as business-related, they may be considered taxable income. Additionally, employers have limited oversight over device security and usage.
Reimbursement for Personal Phone Use
Reimbursements are nontaxable if they are for business use, are reasonably calculated not to exceed actual expenses, and are not a substitute for wages.
Employers appreciate reimbursements for personal phone use for several reasons. Firstly, they only pay for actual business-related expenses, which can help contain costs. Additionally, allowing employees to use their personal devices reduces the company’s need to provide equipment.
However, there are also drawbacks to this approach. A significant concern is the administrative burden, as employees are required to submit detailed expense reports and receipts. Moreover, some employees may be hesitant to share information about their phone usage.
Best Practices for Employers
-
- Establish Clear Policies: Define eligibility, usage expectations, and reimbursement procedures.
- Document Business Necessity: Maintain records demonstrating the business reasons for providing stipends or reimbursements.
- Monitor Compliance: Regularly review policies and practices to ensure they align with IRS guidelines.
Conclusion
Selecting the appropriate method for employee cell phone use depends on your organization’s specific needs, budget, and operational considerations. By understanding the tax implications and weighing the pros and cons of each approach, business owners can make informed decisions that support both business objectives and employee satisfaction.